Please help me choose!

I’ve been so conflicted on whether to keep my 1.5 ct round brilliant or to go for the 1.7 ct oval diamond.

If I do get the round I’d ask for a slightly thinner band and claw like prongs.

I love the shine of the round but I love the shape of the oval.

I’m also wondering if I do go for the round should I keep it as a solitary or add two small diamonds on each side.

I’m so conflicted!

Seeking opinions.

Which do you like best?

I’m sorry the photo quality is not the best.